The Nice Guys (2016) Movie Review: A Hilarious Detective Story With Perfect Chemistry
The Nice Guys is the kind of movie that feels like it shouldn't work as well as it does. It combines a murder mystery, crime thriller, buddy comedy, and 1970s Los Angeles setting into one surprisingly entertaining story.
Directed by Shane Black, the movie follows two completely different men who are forced to work together to investigate the disappearance of a young woman.
Jackson Healy is a tough private enforcer who gets paid to scare people away.
Holland March is a private detective who is much less impressive than he wants people to believe.
Together, they make one of the most entertaining detective partnerships in recent comedy.
Warning: Spoilers ahead.
The Story
The movie takes place in 1970s Los Angeles.
Holland March is a private detective who mostly works on small cases. He's good at finding people, but he's also irresponsible, dishonest, and more interested in getting paid than solving a mystery.
Jackson Healy is very different.
Healy isn't really a traditional detective. People hire him when they want someone threatened or beaten up.
Their lives collide when Healy is hired to scare March away from a woman named Amelia.
Healy successfully intimidates March, but things become complicated when Amelia suddenly disappears.
Soon afterward, Healy himself becomes a target.
The two men realize that Amelia's disappearance is connected to something much larger.
What starts as a simple missing-person case turns into a dangerous investigation involving murder, corruption, the automobile industry, pornography, and a mysterious film.
Holland March
Ryan Gosling plays Holland March, and his performance is one of the movie's biggest strengths.
March is not the smooth, confident detective that movies usually give us.
He's clumsy.
He's easily frightened.
He's often dishonest.
And he has a habit of making terrible decisions.
But he's also surprisingly good at figuring things out.
His greatest weakness is that he doesn't always have the courage to deal with the consequences of his discoveries.
March also has a daughter, Holly, who is far more responsible than he is.
Their relationship gives the movie an emotional center.
Holly constantly sees through her father's lies and excuses, while March tries to convince himself that he's doing a better job than he actually is.
Jackson Healy
Russell Crowe plays Jackson Healy, the perfect opposite of March.
Healy is physically intimidating and knows how to handle himself in a fight.
He doesn't waste time talking when violence will solve the problem.
But beneath his tough exterior, Healy has a strong sense of right and wrong.
He doesn't like people hurting innocent people, particularly women.
That moral code is what eventually turns his job into something more complicated.
Healy initially sees March as an incompetent detective who is getting in the way.
But over time, he begins to respect him.
Their friendship develops naturally because neither man completely understands why they need the other.
The Best Part: March and Healy
The chemistry between Ryan Gosling and Russell Crowe is the heart of the movie.
Their personalities are completely different.
Healy is serious.
March is nervous.
Healy is strong.
March is usually trying to avoid getting hurt.
Healy wants to solve problems directly.
March often makes them much worse.
Their arguments and reactions create some of the funniest moments in the film.
The movie doesn't need to force the comedy.
A lot of it comes naturally from watching two completely different people deal with the same situation.
March's fear also makes his partnership with Healy especially funny.
He knows Healy can protect him, so he often hides behind him when things become dangerous.
Holly March
Angourie Rice plays Holly, March's teenage daughter.
Holly is one of the smartest people in the movie.
She understands that her father isn't particularly responsible, but she still cares about him.
More importantly, she becomes involved in the investigation instead of simply watching from the sidelines.
Holly often provides the moral perspective that March and Healy lack.
She doesn't understand why adults keep making complicated decisions when the obvious answer is usually right in front of them.
Her involvement also raises the stakes.
March isn't only trying to solve a mystery.
He's trying to keep his daughter safe.
The Mystery
The investigation eventually leads March and Healy toward Amelia and a group of people connected to the production of an adult film.
The film contains evidence connected to the automobile industry's attempt to hide information about pollution and environmental damage.
This turns the mystery into something much bigger.
People are being killed because the film could expose powerful interests.
The detectives initially don't understand what they're dealing with.
They keep finding clues that appear unrelated.
But eventually, the pieces begin fitting together.
The Los Angeles Setting
One of the movie's most memorable features is its 1970s setting.
The cars, clothing, music, parties, offices, and neighborhoods give the film a distinctive personality.
Los Angeles feels like more than just a backdrop.
The city is filled with wealthy people, criminals, celebrities, private investigators, and corrupt businesses.
The movie uses that environment to create a world where almost everyone seems to be hiding something.
It also gives the film a classic detective-movie atmosphere while allowing the comedy to feel modern.
The Action
Although The Nice Guys is primarily a comedy, it has plenty of action.
Healy handles most of the physical fighting, while March usually finds himself desperately trying to survive.
Their different abilities create some creative action sequences.
One of the funniest things about the movie is that March rarely looks like an action hero.
When something goes wrong, he panics.
When someone starts shooting, he tries to hide.
When he needs to fight, things usually go badly.
This makes the action more unpredictable because the movie isn't afraid to let its main characters fail.
What Makes the Comedy Work?
The humor is heavily character-driven.
March's reactions are often funnier than the actual situations.
Healy's deadpan personality provides a perfect contrast.
Holly's blunt observations add another layer.
The movie also uses dark humor, physical comedy, awkward conversations, and unexpected violence.
Shane Black's writing gives the characters plenty of sharp dialogue, but the movie doesn't depend entirely on clever one-liners.
The funniest moments often happen because someone makes a terrible decision at exactly the wrong time.
What Works Best
The biggest strength is obviously the chemistry between Gosling and Crowe.
They make the movie enjoyable even when the mystery becomes complicated.
The supporting characters also work well, particularly Holly.
The 1970s setting gives the film a strong visual identity, while the detective story provides enough mystery to keep the plot moving.
Another strength is that the movie doesn't make its characters perfect.
March is a terrible detective in many situations.
Healy is capable of making mistakes.
Holly is a teenager who gets involved in dangerous situations.
Their imperfections make them feel more entertaining and unpredictable.
What Doesn't Work as Well
The biggest weakness is that the mystery can become complicated.
There are several groups, characters, and motives involved, and it can take a while to understand how everything connects.
Some of the plot details are also less important than the characters.
If you're watching primarily for the mystery, parts of the story may feel unnecessarily complicated.
The movie also contains quite a bit of dark and crude humor, so it won't appeal to everyone.
But the character chemistry is strong enough to carry the film through its more complicated moments.
Is The Nice Guys Worth Watching?
Absolutely.
If you enjoy buddy-cop movies, detective stories, or dark comedies, The Nice Guys is an easy recommendation.
It has the familiar setup of two completely different men forced to work together, but the performances make the formula feel fresh.
Ryan Gosling's performance is especially memorable because he embraces March's ridiculous side without turning him into a completely useless character.
Russell Crowe provides the perfect balance as the tougher and more serious partner.
And Holly adds an important emotional element to the story.
Final Thoughts
The Nice Guys is much more than a comedy about two incompetent detectives.
It's a surprisingly well-balanced mixture of mystery, action, humor, and character development.
Holland March and Jackson Healy are complete opposites, but that's exactly why they work together.
March brings nervous energy and accidental detective work.
Healy brings strength and determination.
Holly brings common sense.
Together, they stumble into a conspiracy much bigger than they expected.
The movie also benefits enormously from its 1970s Los Angeles setting, which gives the story a classic crime-movie atmosphere while allowing the comedy to stand out.
What makes The Nice Guys particularly memorable is that the characters don't need to be perfect heroes.
They're messy, scared, stubborn, and often completely out of their depth.
But when it matters, they try to do the right thing.
Final Verdict – The Nice Guys is a stylish, funny, and surprisingly heartfelt detective comedy powered by the excellent chemistry between Ryan Gosling and Russell Crowe. It's the kind of movie that gets better the more time you spend with its characters.
Explore More